|
|
Drawing: Wu Wenfeng
Nanfang Daily (Reporter / Guo Biao) when father and lover having sex in the hotel's sudden death, the son of a paper petition, the father had a lover Dengmou and incident hoteliers Jeong court together, the two defendants for compensation 128 million yuan. Recently, Lo first instance verdict, that there is no evidence that the two defendants to the death of the deceased Ryu, there is no fault, then dismissed the plaintiff's claim.
Incident ▶▶ old man hotel room Sudden Death
April 2, 7 pm, Liu Check a defendant Cheung Chung-run holiday apartments. Half an hour later,woolrich outlet italia, the defendant deng panic from No. 229 out of the room, saying to the waiter on duty at the time and Ryu sexual relations, Liu suddenly fainted. Attendant on duty were immediately call 120 emergency calls and 110 calls. Ambulance staff answered the phone at the hotel after Ryu emergency rescue,http://iloveazure.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=158418, and finally pronounced dead due to rescue invalid.
Luohu District Public Security Bureau police station to the scene bamboo-site investigation and preliminary analysis finds Ryu sudden death during sexual intercourse, the possibility of murder and other criminal cases excluded. City Public Security Bureau of Interpol Battalion Luohu four squadrons issued a "forensic death certificate" that reason Ryu death as "sudden death."
Valentine's mother was actually the father accident ▶▶ old acquaintances
It is understood that Liu and his wife divorced in 2000, but his ex-wife still live together and run a restaurant together. Ryu Ryu super son said in court, deng know his mother,air max 90 pas cher, but also know its father divorced his wife still live together and run a restaurant together. Ryu Super refers Dengmou and father having an affair or illicit sex trade, is illegal and results in father tension, fear and other psychological factors unsafe sexual relations in the process of its occurrence, can easily lead to accidental death. So there is a certain relationship between the father's inevitable death and Dengmou fault, Dengmou shall bear fault liability.
Ryu Super Meanwhile alleged father is Jeong-run hotel in the occurrence of accidental death, the father's death there is a certain relationship with a xiang necessarily the fault of the apartment, the apartment shall be liable for the fault of a Xiang liability. Then sued the two defendants to pay the plaintiff the immediate family of Liu death compensation totaling 1,284,430 yuan.
Chamber debate ▶▶ done accident rescue obligations
The defendant said in court Dengmou defense, in addition to their own sex and the dead, there is no implementation of the deceased may cause death of any violations. Human behavior is very common breed of instinctive behavior, sexual behavior itself does not cause the death of people, so there is no causal relationship between the deaths occurred between himself and the deceased's sex with the deceased. In addition,moncler pas cher, after the accident of the deceased, they would do to the ordinary normal people can do to rescue obligations.
The defendant Jeong reply that the direct cause of death Ryu is its illegal or unethical behavior, the root cause of their disease leading to sudden death, the result of his death,moncler outlet italia, or may be due to changes in time, diet,http://store.shopping.yahoo.co.jp/juraice/190484-j8400.html, fitness and other factors change, but not because of a change of venue (hotels, restaurants, guest houses or other) rather reversed death results Ryu with their no relationship.
▶▶ judgment may but need not bear responsibility for moral condemnation
Luohu Court after hearing that,moncler outlet milano,http://sjh.bbs.windplay.cn/forum-53-1.html?mod=spacecp&ac=blog&blogid=, according to "test" and "forensic death certificate" issued by the public security department, Liu's death is sudden death, and did not examine the harmful substances, and the public security authorities also ruled out the possibility of homicide. The defendant and the deceased Dengmou occur between men and women, although the act may be subject to moral condemnation, but has not committed offenses death Dengmou presence and Ryu fault.
Although the defendant Jeong-run guesthouse no change of business registration, but there is no causal relationship between this behavior and Liu's death, the staff hired Jeong fainted after learning that Liu had immediately call 110,120. In conclusion, the evidence submitted by the plaintiff can not prove the existence of the two defendants to death Ryu's fault, it can not prove that the two defendants committed the offense leading to the death of Liu.
Because the plaintiff claims the two defendants liable for the death of Liu's lack of factual and legal basis, the court then dismissed the plaintiff's claim. |
|
發表於 2015-12-12 19:35:22
收藏